Siesta Key Neighborhoods
SIESTA KEY, FL

Siesta Key Neighborhoods

Suncoast Dreams Real Estate Team at Fine Properties

Compare Siesta Key neighborhoods, condos, houses and amenities. Explore current listings and live market reports, then plan your next step with Vince Vizzaccaro at Fine Properties.

THE MARKET AT A GLANCE

Siesta Key housing market

Open the live report for active listings, recent sales, prices, days on market and months of inventory. Statistics refresh with MLS data. Compare condos and houses separately using the reports below.

FIND YOUR AREA

Siesta Key neighborhood guide

Compare all 26 neighborhoods. Y = Yes; N = No. Swipe sideways to see every column.

Neighborhood Also in Home types Builder(s) HOA CDD Gated Clubhouse Pool Fitness Pickleball Golf Age-restricted (55+) Notes Report
Bay Island   SF     N N         N N North-key single-family neighborhood off Siesta Drive; bayfront and near-bay lots. Coming soon
Bayou Louise   SF     N N         N N Single-family bayou-front neighborhood; bayou / waterfront lots. Coming soon
Casarina   Condo   $$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Gulf-front condo on Crescent Beach; resort-style building. Coming soon
Crescent Royale   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Crescent Beach condo on Beach Road; Gulf-front / beach setting. Coming soon
Crystal Sands   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Gulf-front condo on Crescent Beach corridor. Coming soon
Dolphin Bay   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Bayfront condo community. Coming soon
Excelsior Beach to Bay   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Midnight Pass Road condo spanning Gulf to bay; Gulf-front and bayfront exposures by unit. Coming soon
Gulf and Bay Club   Condo   $$$$$ N   Y Y Y   N N Condo community with Gulf and bay exposure; resort-style amenities. Coming soon
Hidden Harbor   SF     N N         N N Single-family neighborhood; harbour / canal waterfront lots. Coming soon
Horizons West   Condo   $$$$ N     Y     N N Gulf-front / beach condo community. Coming soon
Island House   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N     Y     N N Gulf-front / near-beach condo. Coming soon
Jamaica Royale   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Gulf-front / beach condo community. Coming soon
Midnight Cove   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Gulf-front condo community on Midnight Pass Road (phases I & II). Coming soon
Palm Bay Club   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Condo community on the key; near-beach / bay setting by building. Coming soon
Peppertree Bay   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Bay-side condo community; bayfront setting. Coming soon
Point of Rocks   SF     N N         N N Small single-family enclave at Point of Rocks; Gulf-front and near-beach homes along the rocky point south of Crescent Beach. Coming soon
Roberts Point   SF     N N         N N Single-family point neighborhood; bayfront / waterfront lots. Coming soon
Sanderling Club   SF   $$$$$ N Y Y Y     N N Private gated single-family club community; Gulf-front and near-beach estate lots. Coming soon
Sandy Hook   SF     N N         N N Single-family neighborhood on Sandy Hook Road; near-beach / island streets. Coming soon
Sarasota Beach   SF     N N         N N Beach Road single-family area near Siesta Beach / Crescent Beach; Gulf-front and near-beach homes. Coming soon
Sarasota Surf & Racquet   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N   Y Y     N N Gulf-front condo on Crescent Beach with racquet amenities. Coming soon
Sea Club   Condo   $$$$ N     Y     N N Crescent Beach condo community; Gulf-front / beach setting. Coming soon
Sea Shell   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N     Y     N N Gulf-front condo on Midnight Pass Road (Crescent Beach corridor). Coming soon
Siesta Breakers   Condo   $$$$–$$$$$ N     Y     N N Gulf-front condo on Crescent Beach corridor. Coming soon
Siesta Cove   SF     N           N N Single-family neighborhood; canal / cove setting. Coming soon
Siesta Isles   SF     N N         N N Large single-family neighborhood (~280+ homes) with canal streets; canal / bayou setting; docks on many lots. Coming soon

HOA levels are relative and approximate; CDD indicates whether a Community Development District applies. Verify current fees with the HOA and the county tax bill.

BUYING IN SIESTA KEY

Let’s narrow your search.

Not sure which Siesta Key neighborhood fits? Book a 15-minute call.

Book a Call
SELLING IN SIESTA KEY

Start with your home’s value.

Own a home in Siesta Key? Get a pricing visit at your home.

Request a Visit

Or call 941-220-4000

YOUR QUESTIONS, ANSWERED

Buying a home on Siesta Key

How are the condo and house reports separated?

Condo reports use the MLS condo category; house reports use single-family residential. Villas follow their MLS classification. The full report also includes townhomes. Vacant land is excluded.

What should I review about association fees?

Request the current budget, fee schedule and governing documents for the specific property. The table shows relative HOA levels, not fee amounts.

How do I compare flood exposure and insurance?

Review current flood mapping for the address and obtain property-specific insurance quotes.

Can I rent out a property?

Review the current local rules and association documents for the specific address, including lease duration and approval requirements.

How do I receive monthly market updates?

Open a report and select Save report & get monthly updates. The report uses the most recent six months of sold listings.

Take the next step

Featured Siesta Key listings

8900 Blind Pass Road Unit A303, Sarasota
$799,900
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Fishermans Cove SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Top-floor, turnkey beachfront living with your own assigned boat slip—experience the best of both worlds on the quiet southern end of world-renowned Siesta Key in Sarasota, Florida. Breathtaking Gulf views greet you from every room of this beautifully remodeled 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom condo, where tranquil turquoise waters and a beachfront setting create an extraordinary coastal retreat. An enclosed patio with hurricane-impact windows offers a cruise-ship-like perspective over the Gulf. Open the windows to welcome coastal breezes and the soothing sound of waves along the shore. With the Gulf on one side and Blind Pass Lagoon on the other, enjoy both sunrise and sunset, sand between your toes, and boating adventures from your assigned slip. Launch a kayak or paddleboard to explore the waterways, or head out by boat toward Sarasota Bay and the open Gulf with no bridges along the way. Thoughtfully remodeled throughout, the interior features ceramic wood-look tile, soft coastal colors, updated fans and light fixtures, and an open floor plan designed to showcase the views. The beautifully renovated kitchen features granite countertops, custom wood cabinetry with soft-close doors, a tile backsplash, and stainless steel appliances. An opened kitchen wall enhances sightlines, while an additional glass door brings in views of Blind Pass Lagoon, where wildlife, kayakers, and boaters provide an ever-changing backdrop. Beautifully appointed furnishings complement inviting spaces for dining and entertaining, including a kitchen breakfast bar, a full dining area, and additional dining space on the enclosed patio. Thoughtful furniture with built-in storage and an additional interior closet provide room for beach essentials. Wake to water views in the primary bedroom, complete with an expansive walk-in closet housing a full-size washer and dryer—a rare convenience in this community for owners and renters alike. The thoughtfully renovated bathroom features a glass-enclosed walk-in shower, an updated vanity with a granite countertop, and updated lighting. Additional highlights include air conditioning updated in 2023 and a new building roof in 2025. Monthly fees include water, sewer, internet, and cable. Enjoy long beach walks, a heated community swimming pool, boating, kayaking, and fishing—all at your fingertips. Walk to waterfront dining at Turtles Restaurant and Ophelia’s on the Bay, or take the free trolley to Siesta Key Village for dining, live entertainment, and charming shops. Discover downtown Sarasota’s cultural offerings, including ballet, symphony performances, the Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall, and the farmers market, with convenient access to Sarasota Bradenton International Airport. Whether you seek a turnkey beachfront escape, an investment opportunity with one-week minimum rentals, or a full-time coastal residence, this exceptional Fishermans Cove condo brings together beachfront beauty and a bonus boating lifestyle if desired!

8900 Blind Pass Road Unit A303, Sarasota

Sarasota
$1,549,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Siesta Isles SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
YOUR FURNISHED SIESTA KEY ESCAPE—BEAUTIFULLY REIMAGINED This extensively and tastefully renovated 3 bedroom, 3 and 1 half bath with quality finishes throughout has been meticulously maintained and is being offered furnished. With 2300 square feet under air, a 2 car garage and large pool with panoramic screened cage welcomes you with tropical landscaping, a circular paver driveway, and inviting island style. Renovated in 2017–2018 this home offers a relaxed living space that with substantial improvements throughout. Each bedroom features its own private en suite bathroom, complemented by a separate guest half bath. All bathrooms were completely redone during the renovation. Improvements included a new metal roof, PGT WinGuard Aluminum 700 Series impact windows throughout, all new doors, plumbing, electrical, air-conditioning and ducts, drywall, lighting, and tile flooring. The kitchen features white cabinetry, a contrasting island with seating, and an impressive appliance selection: a Thermador gas stove and oven/microwave combination, Bosch dishwasher, and Café refrigerator. A 250-gallon propane tank supplies the gas stove and tankless water heater. Open living and dining spaces provide a welcoming setting for entertaining, with warm-toned tile flooring and views of the surrounding greenery. Outside, the pool, paver deck, and lanai invite relaxed outdoor living. A Panoramic View pool enclosure enhances the outlook, creating a beautiful setting for morning coffee, poolside dining, and quiet afternoons. Additional conveniences include central vacuum throughout the home, wiring for ceiling fans in every room, and an oversized two-car garage. Thoughtfully updated with quality finishes throughout, this welcoming Siesta Key retreat is ready for your next chapter of island living.

Sarasota

6512 Midnight Pass Road Unit 206, Sarasota
$1,690,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Crescent Siesta Key SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Experience Luxury Living on South Siesta Key! Welcome to your dream condo, perfectly situated on the pristine shores of Siesta Key. This stunning Gulf-front property offers unparalleled beach living, making it the ultimate coastal retreat. This corner unit is offered turnkey furnished, ready for immediate enjoyment. Impeccably designed in a contemporary beachfront style, 1600 sw. ft., 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence presents an expansive floor plan highlighted by a gourmet kitchen featuring top-tier appliances, granite countertops, soft close cabinets, and refined accents. The kitchen seamlessly transitions into a spacious living area accented by an artistic terrazzo accent wall opening onto an expansive terrace. Your terrace has a built-in outdoor kitchen, gas grill, and private access to the resistance heated lap pool with child safety fence/doors. The terrazzo wall continues through both bedrooms adding a sophisticated beach ambiance. Master bath featuring dual sinks, a private toilet with automatic bidet amenities, deep soaking tub, and large walk-in shower. The additional bedroom for your guests includes an ensuite bath which offers ample space. Wifi and remote controlled thermostat, door lock, gate, building, and beach access. Plus two owner’s storage closets for rental convenience. This property serves as a tranquil retreat in an exceptional location, very quiet with very little street noise, whether you're seeking a permanent residence, a vacation getaway, or a profitable rental property. The building boasts an array of amenities designed to elevate everyday living, including onsite management for added convenience and closed circuit camera/surveillance system for security. Residents can enjoy a beachfront heated pool, spa, and resistance lap pool right outside your door. A fitness center ensures residents stay active. Dive into one of two pools or spa overlooking the beach, walk the white sugar sand beaches that stretch for miles, create fabulous meals in the outdoor kitchen and dine al fresco with a view of the gulf amidst beautifully landscaped gardens or sink into a chaise lounge under the loggias with a great book. At Crescent Siesta Key, embrace a lifestyle of comfort, luxury, and seaside serenity with all amenities conveniently at your disposal.

6512 Midnight Pass Road Unit 206, Sarasota

5970 Midnight Pass Road Unit 177, Sarasota
$650,000
1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Palm Bay Club SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Beach to bay, turnkey and ready to enjoy—this one-bedroom residence at the Palm Bay Club offers an approachable way to own a piece of the Siesta Key lifestyle without sacrificing the amenities that make this community so desirable. Positioned on the Gulf side of Midnight Pass Road, the powder-white sands and turquoise waters of Crescent Beach are just steps from your door. Inside, the thoughtfully designed floor plan makes excellent use of every space. Handsome vinyl plank flooring provides a durable, low-maintenance foundation for relaxed coastal décor, while the kitchen pairs crisp white cabinetry with bold black granite countertops and stainless-steel appliances. The open living and dining area is comfortably furnished and ready for everything from quiet mornings to recharging between Siesta Key adventures. An enclosed lanai has been incorporated into the living space, where three large glass sliders welcome abundant natural light and open to capture the island breeze. The peaceful bedroom features two beds to maximize guest accommodations, while the updated bath continues the condo’s fresh, easygoing aesthetic. Offered turnkey furnished, this residence makes the transition from closing day to beach day refreshingly simple. And at Palm Bay Club, ownership extends well beyond your front door. Enjoy private Crescent Beach access, two heated swimming pools, a waterfront hot tub overlooking the Intracoastal, fitness center, lighted tennis and pickleball courts, BBQ grills, fishing pier and boat docks available for daily rental. With a three-night minimum rental policy and established onsite management, this efficient one-bedroom residence presents a compelling combination of personal enjoyment, rental flexibility and exceptional Siesta Key value.

5970 Midnight Pass Road Unit 177, Sarasota

1207 Sharswood Lane, Sarasota
$3,195,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Spice Bay SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
LIVE THE SIESTA KEY LIFESTYLE IN SPICE BAY—an intimate, gated enclave of just 14 estate-sized homesites in one of Siesta Key’s most distinctive Intracoastal communities. Custom built by award-winning builder Ryan Perrone of Nautilus Homes, this sophisticated residence offers approximately 3,235 square feet of beautifully designed SINGLE-LEVEL LIVING with exceptional craftsmanship, privacy, and effortless indoor-outdoor entertaining. Offered FURNISHED, this exceptional home is ready for you to immediately begin enjoying the Siesta Key lifestyle. From the moment you enter through the impressive mahogany front door, a dramatic wall of glass sliders draws your eye to the lush tropical surroundings and expansive outdoor living areas beyond. Filled with NATURAL LIGHT, the home blends refined finishes with relaxed “barefoot elegance,” creating a coastal retreat that feels both luxurious and inviting. The thoughtfully designed floor plan features 3 BEDROOMS, EACH WITH ITS OWN ENSUITE BATH, providing exceptional privacy and comfort for family and guests. The spacious primary suite includes a private den/study and a luxurious spa-inspired bath, while the additional bedrooms are generously sized and beautifully appointed. A PRIVATE CASITA LOCATED JUST OFF THE PORCH adds even more flexibility—perfect for visiting guests, extended family, a private retreat, studio, or home office. Throughout the home, you’ll find wide-plank oil-finished wood flooring, handcrafted details, custom closets and built-ins that reflect the quality of this custom residence. At the heart of the home, the GOURMET CHEF’S KITCHEN was created for entertaining and features a 6-burner gas range, steam oven, two dishwashers, generous workspace and a large walk-in pantry. Open the sliders and embrace true Florida indoor-outdoor living. The extended courtyard and lanai enjoy DESIRABLE SOUTHERN EXPOSURE and a private tropical setting—perfect for morning coffee, entertaining friends, relaxing with an evening cocktail or unwinding in the spa. For boating enthusiasts, enjoy access to a DEEP-WATER BOAT DOCK WITH A 13,000-LB LIFT, making it easy to spend your days exploring Sarasota Bay and the surrounding waterways. An oversized THREE-CAR TANDEM GARAGE provides exceptional space for vehicles, storage and all your island toys. Spice Bay offers the rare combination of PRIVACY AND CONVENIENCE on Siesta Key. Walk or bike to the beach, nearby shops and restaurants, spend your days enjoying the world-famous quartz sands of Siesta Key Beach, then head downtown for Sarasota’s celebrated dining, arts and cultural scene. This exceptional TURNKEY FURNISHED custom residence captures the very best of luxury coastal living—private, refined and unmistakably Siesta Key.

1207 Sharswood Lane, Sarasota

8776 Midnight Pass Road Unit C101, Sarasota
$995,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Island Reef SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code
Experience the best of Siesta Key living at Island Reef, a desirable Gulf-to-Bay community on the peaceful southern end of the island. Offering 1,875 square feet of living space, this two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath ground-floor condominium features one of the community’s largest floor plans, providing generous living spaces and a comfortable coastal retreat. Ideally positioned as one of the closest residences to both the community swimming pool and beach access, the condominium features a private walkout patio overlooking the beautifully maintained grounds and pool. The ground-floor setting allows for easy outdoor access without the need for elevators, while a nearby covered carport adds everyday convenience. Inside, the residence features fresh interior paint, a beautifully renovated primary bathroom, a remodeled laundry room, and new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout both bedrooms, closets, and all two-and-a-half bathrooms. Significant improvements include replacement of the vertical iron plumbing pipes throughout the residence, along with an air conditioning system and water heater replaced approximately one year ago. The kitchen features appliances approximately five years old and offers an opportunity to personalize the space to your taste. With its expansive floor plan, substantial updates, and inviting indoor and outdoor living spaces, this residence offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy the relaxed coastal lifestyle of Siesta Key.

8776 Midnight Pass Road Unit C101, Sarasota

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!